The 25 Best Insurance Agencies in Tucson
Home, auto, life, and business insurance. Ranked from 5,594 Google reviews across the Tucson metro.
- Updated October 2026
- 71 met the bar
- 4.76 average rating
The short answerThe highest ranked insurance agencies in Tucson right now are Tom DeBerry - State Farm Insurance Agent (5.0 stars, 709 reviews), Emily Cadamagnani - State Farm Insurance Agent (5.0 stars, 226 reviews), and Fernando Martinez - State Farm Insurance Agent (5.0 stars, 214 reviews). They come out on top of 71 eligible businesses after weighting each rating by its review volume.
- 1
Tom DeBerry - State Farm Insurance Agent
Insurance agency - 2
Emily Cadamagnani - State Farm Insurance Agent
Insurance agency - 3
Fernando Martinez - State Farm Insurance Agent
Insurance agency
- 4
- 5
- 6
- 7
- 8
- 9
- 10
- 11
- 12
- 13
- 14
- 15
- 16
- 17
- 18
- 19
- 20
- 21
- 22
- 23
- 24
- 25
How this list was made
We pulled 100 Tucson-area insurance agencies from Google Maps, then kept the 71 with a rating of 4.0 or higher and at least 10 reviews. The average rating in this group is 4.76 stars.
Ratings with only a few reviews are pulled toward that average, so a business needs a real track record to reach the top. Nobody pays to be here. Read the full method.
- Businesses reviewed
- 100
- Met the bar
- 71
- Average rating
- 4.76
- Reviews behind this list
- 5,594
Questions people ask
Who is the best insurance agency in Tucson?
As of October 2026, Tom DeBerry - State Farm Insurance Agent ranks first among 71 eligible Tucson insurance agencies, with a 5.0 star Google rating across 709 reviews. Emily Cadamagnani - State Farm Insurance Agent and Fernando Martinez - State Farm Insurance Agent round out the top three.
Which Tucson insurance agencies have the most reviews?
Of the 25 insurance agencies ranked on this page, Buy LowCost Insurance (1,097), Tom DeBerry - State Farm Insurance Agent (709), and Brett Overstreet - State Farm Insurance Agent (507) have the most Google reviews.
How did you rank these insurance agencies?
We started with 100 Tucson-area businesses from Google Maps and kept the 71 with at least a 4.0 star rating and 10 or more reviews. Each rating is then weighted by how many reviews back it up, so a perfect score from a handful of reviews does not outrank a near-perfect score from hundreds.
Can a business pay to rank higher?
No. Positions come only from public Google ratings and review volume. Claiming or updating a listing is free and does not change its rank.
More professional services in Tucson
Own a Tucson business?
Every listing is free. Claim yours to correct your phone, hours, or website, or tell us about a category we are missing. Claiming never changes a rank.
